Slacktivism: Good or Bad?

I recall the wave of French flags that Facebook users laid over their profile photos this year and my thought process around deciding not to follow suit although many of my FB pals had done so. When I first starting reading about the story my reaction was that this was a simple way to demonstrate support and compassion for a country and city suffering from a senseless attack. I was about to change my profile and follow suit, but then I start reading more posts (not from anyone I actually knew) and discovered that doing so was actually controversial.

What could be controversial at first glance? As I read on I found that those not changing their profile agreed that is was senseless tragedy as well, but did not feel this was the best way to address the tragedy. There were various reasons for and against, but the one post that stood out for me the most was by a person that wanted the whole event minimized in any form of media. Their argument was that the support was appreciated, yet they did not want a media outpouring to give the terrorists any extension of “fame”. For me, at this time, the argument made a great deal of sense. We’ve used a similar arguments before to avoid glorifying murderers and rapists. So I did not change by FB profile.

At the time I had no idea that this topic is part of the whole slacktivist debate. After reading though the articles from this past week and considering some of the activism projects in the digital world, I’m still a bit uncertain about whether slacktivism is a good or bad thing. This graph gives a quick overview of what would be considered slacktivism vs activism, but after reading more about this topic, I do not feel one is necessarily more effective or better than the other.

5359831_orig
Graph from Weebly

Both Branstetter and Rosmarin talk about the common critiques of slacktivists being shallow and just appearing to be socially conscious when more could be done with real action. This could be in the form of donations or other active on the ground work. However, Branstetter argues that slacktivism is actually dead as millennial actually use the digital world to equip themselves to protest both digitally and by foot while Rosmarin points out that slacktivism does create awareness while cynics of slacktivists will actually encourage these better informed individuals to make better choices and at some point take action.

So when I consider slacktivism in this light, it is neither good or bad. It is important to consider what you share and like along with why you do so. It should not be about being appearing to be socially conscious or raising something contentious for the sake of shock value, but engaging in digital activity that has meaning to you. Groetzinger notes that slacktivism in larger networked numbers provides support to those actually on the ground and that those actively engaged in digital activism are more likely to become involved in real life. Therefore, slacktivism can be a mechanism for individuals to learn about and become better informed before making a conscious decision about their on foot involvement.

The key here though is actively engaged. Slacktivism cannot be about signing every petition that floats across your screen or shouting out comments for shock value. It must be a way to learn about injustices and challenges (both locally and globally) and find out how you could actively engage digitally and if you are compelled and able to do so on foot as well. Slacktivism, as many would argue creates much greater awareness than ever before so individuals and as a collective we can influence positive change. This video gives a simple overview of how such awareness through the digital world is actually a modern form of activism. We can make better choices and informed decisions by engaging online in meaningful ways and find ways to influence change without necessarily going to traditional activism methods (although there is still a place for that too).

This debate is far from over, but more than anything is has allowed me to think more consciously about what I post or engage in online. I was already doing it thinking back to the flag example, but now this whole concept of online activism has made me start to consider what I have maybe commented, liked or shared without considering the full message behind that story and what activist message I am sending. Digital activism is creating self-awareness and understanding what messages you support by sharing. I do not know that I will ever be as dedicated as Martha Payne, but her work is proof that digital campaigns such as hers can be very effective in informing and advocating for change, which is by definition activism.

Advertisements

8 thoughts on “Slacktivism: Good or Bad?

  1. I think that you have some excellent points here Nathan, I agree with your whole point on changing disagreeing with the Facebook profile picture. In addition, I would like to point out that Facebook’s choice of who should be deserving of a “flag filter” is problematic. How often have we seen the same pictures of non-western countries in those same “flag-filters”? None that I’m aware of. For example, following the attack in Belgium there was also a attack in Iraq killing numerous people. Facebook did nothing for Iraq. This makes me question, “do we value western lives over non-western lives?”

    As for your social activism, I agree it is much to easy for us to share a post, like a photo, but when it comes down to it. It is much harder to get on your feet and do something about it. However, as I have seen, social media is a vehicle that allows social justice issues to be heard. For example, #RIISup, a hashtag that Raquel Bellefleur created has gained a lot of media attention recently. Just from getting it retweeted and starting a discussion on Twitter. (I recommend that you should check it out). Social media and activism can go hand in hand if it is done correctly.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Good point Curtis about what is recognized by FB or the mainstream culture for that matter. That is why I
      I think it is so important to consider what we share or like on social media. It is a powerful tool and I agree with you we can use it as a way to be be activists, I just hope we are conscious activists learning and engaging.

      So glad to see you and Raquel engaged in such important topics as individuals and future educators!

      Like

    1. I just think it is cook that a young kid has found a way to be so active about a topic that directly impacts her and her peers around her. As students or adults, we just need to find those topics that inspire or connect with us. We do not need to be advocates for everything, but something.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s